WordPress runs a large share of the web, and for good reason: it is familiar, flexible, and has a plugin for almost everything. Next.js is a modern framework for building fast websites and web apps, used by many of the products you use every day. Both can produce an excellent small business website. They suit different businesses.
We build with Next.js, so read this knowing that. We have also rebuilt plenty of WordPress sites, and we will tell you when WordPress is the better answer.
Speed
A well-built Next.js site serves pages as pre-built files from servers close to the visitor, so pages typically load very quickly, even on a phone. WordPress can be fast too, but many sites slow down over time as themes, page builders, and plugins pile up. Page speed affects both how many visitors stay and how Google judges your site.
Security and maintenance
Because WordPress is so popular, it is a constant target. Most hacked WordPress sites are compromised through an outdated plugin or theme, which means updates are a permanent chore. A pre-built Next.js site has no admin login on the public site and far fewer moving parts to attack, so there is much less to patch.
Editing your own content
This is WordPress's strongest card. If your team publishes often and wants to change layouts without a developer, WordPress is hard to beat. Next.js sites can be connected to an editor too, through a headless content system, but for many small businesses that change their site a few times a year, simple edits handled by the studio are cheaper than maintaining an editor.
Running costs
- WordPress: hosting, premium theme and plugin licences that renew yearly, plus time or a retainer for updates and security.
- Next.js: low-cost hosting for a static or mostly static site, and no plugin licences. Changes need a developer unless a content editor is added.
SEO
Both can rank well. WordPress makes SEO approachable through plugins. Next.js gives full control over page titles, structured data, sitemaps, and speed, and rewards a site built properly from the start. The bigger factors are the same either way: useful content, one page per service, and a fast, mobile-friendly site.
AI features and growth
If your website may grow into a web app, with customer accounts, bookings, an AI chat assistant, or a client portal, Next.js handles that in the same codebase. WordPress can add these through plugins, but complex features often end up fighting the platform.
What this looks like on real small business sites
The small business sites we have built recently all run on Next.js. Craigengillan, a Scottish estate with holiday cottages and events, needed live availability from its Lodgify booking system on every cottage page, plus an editorial journal for local search. Consultation Catalyst needed fast, server-rendered content pages and a structured enquiry flow. CM Speedrunners needed a custom storefront with a multi-step quote builder and Discord and YouTube integrations.
Each of those mixes a marketing site with something closer to an app: live data, a booking or quote flow, or an integration. That mix is where Next.js earns its place. A site that is only a few pages of text, updated weekly by the owner, is still often better on WordPress.
Moving from WordPress without losing rankings
- Export every page and post, and list every URL Google currently has indexed.
- Keep the same URLs where possible, and set permanent redirects for any that change.
- Carry over page titles, descriptions, and headings that already rank.
- Rebuild forms and test that every enquiry actually arrives.
- Resubmit the sitemap on launch day and watch Search Console for errors for a few weeks.
Which should you choose?
- Choose WordPress if you publish frequently, want to edit layouts yourself, or rely on a specific plugin such as a membership or events system.
- Choose Next.js if speed, security, and low maintenance matter most, if you change the site occasionally, or if the site may grow into an app or add AI features.
- Keep your current WordPress site if it is fast, secure, and doing its job. Rebuilding something that works is rarely the best use of money.